Contact Us!
Military, student, and senior discounts


Russell Babcock argues Nevarez v. Katavich to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals

Posted by Russell Babcock | Mar 19, 2018 | 0 Comments

Russell Babcock argues Nevarez v. Katavich to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals

On December  Russell Babcock argued the case of Nevarez v  Katavich  (12-56058) to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in Pasadena.

To Listen to the Entire Oral argument, click here.

Mr. Nevarez was convicted largely upon the word of his young son who told a police officer investigating the case that , “daddy had a gun” and that “daddy had threatened to kill mommy when he wanted.”  The problem with the statements was that the son was never presented as a witness by the prosecution.  The Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution requires in most instances that when a witnesses statement is to be used in court, it must be subject to cross-examination.  Without allowing the defense to have a chance to cross-examine the witness, the testimony may inherently be unreliable  i.e. coached by mom or mistaken.

The argument was engaging.  Justice Graber appeared to recognize that there has been a violation but that it might have been “harmless.”  Justice Callahan questioned whether the court should rule on the issue because the attorneys below did not properly preserve it.  Justice Gould appeared to suggest that there should be an exception to the Confrontation clause for young witnesses, an idea unprecedented in the law.

This case is important because everyone who is convicted of a crime has the right to be confronted by the witnesses against them  This is what distinguishes the jurisprudence of the United States from countries such as Russia and Venezuela.

I will keep the readers updated on the results on this case.

About the Author

Russell Babcock

Conozca a russell Russell S. Babcock (Founder + Owner) Spanish Speaking Criminal Defense Attorney  (Federal and State Court) The law firm of Russell S. Babcock was formed to provide the highest quality of federal and state criminal defense services at reasonable prices. We are a full service c...


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Contact Us Today

Law Office of Russell Babcock is committed to answering your questions about Border & Immigration Crimes, Federal Crimes, Appeals, Investigations, Drugs & Narcotics, State Crime, Economic Crime, and Homicide law issues in California.

I'll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.

Contact Us

Let us help you with your case!